A friend got this for me years ago for my birthday, which is in October, and it is just the perfect scent to complement the sights and smells of Fall, in my opinion. It's a sweet, naturistic fragrance that reminds me of the best parts of the outdoors around Fall time. I love the aroma of wet Fall leaves and The One is similar to that in a way. It isn't a particularly strong fragrance, which is generally a good thing. It's subtle, but it is definitely noticeable if someone is close to you. I can't imagine anyone disliking this smell, I just think it is much more of a Sept-November fragrance (US) rather than a summer, spring, or winter fragrance. If you're looking for a year-round fragrance, there are definitely better options. But if you're looking to add on to your fragrance collection, I would definitely put The One in there with the best of them. Other fragrances I own and recommend are Versace Per Homme, Versace Dylan, Versace Eau Fraiche, and Polo Black. And yes, I am complimented on how good I smell constantly lol.